Reading large file line by line memory mgmt and performance. Hi i have what i think is a simple problem but after much searching cant seem to find a solution. The matter that i am unable to make decision is which of the above should i use xmldocument or xdocument or xmlreader or linq to xml. This question came up in the forums a little while ago, and i thought it might be interesting to do some comparisons. You can then modify it as necessary, and then put it back into the document library, either as a new document, or replacing the original. Take for example the xdocument class it allows us to use xpath style queries using a linq syntax. What was very interesting is that the memory consumption from 43%. Create an xdocument class with the specified xdeclaration and content.
Once i found out i could pair it easily with the linq namespace in visual studio, without adding more libraries, i ran with it. Searched on the internet for days but found nothing, think the problem is everyone is using vs and. It can be read from a string, stream, url, text reader, or a class derived from the xmlreader the load method brings the document into memory and has overloaded methods available to take data from each of the different formats. Reading xml data using xpathdocument and xmldocument. We just need to create the instance of this class with the specified system. Unfortunately, i dont think i can do something like this. I decided to construct a very simple demo program as shown at. Linq to xml offers easy accessibility to all linq functionalities like standard query operators, programming interface, etc. It creates the new attribute and sets the value to that attribute. This is a class for reading wellformed xhtml with or without a doctype into a. Linq to xml brings two notable improvements to working with large documents. You could try loading your xmldocument from this reader instead of a string its probably the string which is being placed in the loh and causing your problems rather than.
It strictly follows closing node, casesensitive and node name. So, we have a string, that is xml, we want to load it into a xdocument that takes a xdocument. Solved xmldocument vs xdocument vs xmlreader vs linq to. I first came up with a few ways of turning an xmldocument into an xdocument.
Reading an xml document into the dom microsoft docs. Im not sure why there not being code present to perform write operations would have any impact on read performance. Save adds unwanted encoding information from the expert community at experts exchange. Ive got several xml documents that are upwards of 100 300 k in siz. One is to read an xml document using the readonly xpathdocument class and the other is to read an xml document using the editable xmldocument class in the system. I have the xml document being produced correctly thus far. This is primarily a question of performance, relating to both memory and speed. Xdocument 2 points 3 points 4 points 23 days ago the position of the director in frontlevelbehind helps as well for height accuracy but not so much for power for accuracy on target, disregarding distance. This is an old blog post by now, but you really should gc between the runs of xmldocument and xdocument, try switching their order switching the order and see what happens. The following code shows how to get child element from xdocument by name. Limitedtime offer applies to the first charge of a new. Net framework, linq to xml also makes the best use of. Reading data from xml with xdocument showing 16 of 6 messages.
Developers should prefer the classes in the system. Convert tofrom xmldocument and xdocumentxelements github. Provides an older inmemory extensible markup language xml programming interface that enables you to modify xml documents. The real app is a service that runs for weeks at a time, you can watch it accumulate memory using task manager.
There is a nice performance comparison done by joe ferner which augments many earlier studies between xmldocument and xmlreaderxmlwriter. This includes an xml declaration, processing instructions, and comments. I have an xml file stored on an web server and i need to read the data using for a smart device application. I have been parsing wordprocessingml ooxml over the past week using linq to xml and it has been a great learning experience. For such documents, we need to consume the xml with a streaming xmlreader instead. It might over the shortterm since, as you said, the gc runs on its own schedule. So we can define this constructor of the xdocument in this way. When my current project started in 2007, linq was just starting out and i wanted to stay with. Documenttype gets the document type definition dtd for this. Linq to xml is a clean break from the somewhat antiquated dom that we all know and tolerate, and the new api provides many improvements over the dom based xmldocument.
I also need the ability to select indvidual nodes of the xml file. Fast way to convert xmldocument into xdocument marcelos. Xml information is read into memory from different formats. We will use mostly xdocument and xmldocument class to. This method can take a file path, text stream, or xml stream as input. Convert tofrom xmldocument and xdocumentxelements xmllinqconversionextensions. However, some documents really are just too large to efficiently process with an inmemory representation like xdocument. The xdocument class contains the information necessary for a valid xml document. Xmldocument versus xdocument versus xmlreaderxmlwriter. Some hard numbers about xmldocument, xdocument and. Load xml from a file, string, or stream visual basic. The easiest would be xmldocument or xdocument depending on your tasks, also, i would doubt that xdocument without linq to xml would pay off, so consider using linq with that, but xmlreaderxmlwriter can get you top performance. Create a new instance of the xdocument and add xcomment and xelement. An example of this is to transform an object model into an xml document suitable for transmission to a web service.
Working with inmemory open xml documents eric whites blog. Syntaxes are much easier than xmldocument and it requires a minimal amount of code. Creates a new from a file specified by a uri, from an, or from an. Now linq to xml uses xdocument for the same kind of thing. There are two ways to read an xml document in the system.
Search for a value in xml without loading it in memory. Loaded the xml to xdocument, and when i try to parse using doc. Ive decided to use a memorystream, as a memorystream will create a stream that is in memory vs. Get child element from xdocument by name in csharp description.
The code below will load the xml file into the xmldocument or xdocument. Ive noticed that there is some lag when loading this information into an xdocument rather than an xmldocument object. Ive got several xml documents that are upwards of 100 300 k. When you look at xdocument, youll notice it has the xdocument. It will get to out of memory if i create enough of these objects. Xmldocument load function is giving out of memory exception for large xml file5mb rate this. Have you tried examining the memory requirements between the two of them. In a xml file, i have a first element appears only one time with this label.
Net framework gibt es zwei verschiedene klassen, um mit xmldateien zu interagieren. This makes it easier to expand or upgrade to new operating systems, new. Xmldocument vs xdocument vs xmlreader vs linq to xml. For xdocument, the magnitude is not as severe, but still a magnitude.
Blog toc when working with document libraries in sharepoint, you retrieve a document from the document library as a byte array. It is successfully loading the file, but i cant seem to get at the elements. Xmldocument vs xdocument and their usage advance sharp. To populate an xml literal such as an xelement or xdocument object from a file, use the load method. In my days as a developer, ive had to generate xml documents from code numerous times. Dont use this while this does work correctly, it is very inefficient since it converts the whole xml tree to a single string and parses. Some hard numbers about xmldocument, xdocument and xmlreader x86 versus x64. After reading rubberducks link i think xml serialization is what i want to pursue.
I have been using xelement class a lot lately, i was doing some performance tests on this to figure out the difference between this and xmldocument class and here is what i found. Traversing forward from an xelement object via the nextnode property. This makes it easier to expand or upgrade to new operating systems, new applications, or new browsers, without losing data. Encoding, memorystream, xdocument steve gentiles tech blog. Attached is a code snippet of my code and ill try to also attache the xml snippet. Net framework functionalities like debugging, compiletime checking, strong typing and many more to say. At first we have to create sample xml document with some sample data. Paste xml as xlinq xelement visual studio addin scott hanselman. Linq namespace, this class is inherit by xcontainer class. Create an xml document with linq to xml intertech blog. Some hard numbers about xmldocument, xdocument and xmlreader x86 versus x64 in my earlier blog i had summarized from experience and material on the web that was born out by my own observations. Xmldocument versus xdocument versus xmlreaderxmlwriter with aspnet, there are three possible paths to handling xml. Is there a serious performance difference between these two objects. Ive got several xml documents that are upwards of 100 300 k in size.
1461 645 1296 602 324 1435 428 1573 880 674 1578 150 1140 185 875 110 215 858 155 888 336 885 1035 837 1092 1150 978 700 862 205 1327 746 367 1538 911 822 1450 1365 1381 375 1240 1497 75